The Ozark Chicken Salad Sandwich is another non-seafood standout, combining grilled chicken, red grapes, onions, celery, and almonds tossed in mayo and served with lettuce and tomato on a croissant.

Nestled in Toms River, New Jersey, “Shut Up and Eat” isn’t just being bossy – it’s offering some sage advice for anyone lucky enough to visit this charming, no-frills eatery that’s become a beloved ...